Between difference and inequality 1 rogers brubaker published in journal of ethnic and migration studies 41, no. Pluralism assumes that its practice will lead decisionmakers to negotiate solutions that contribute to the common good of the entire society. The guidelines represent general principles that are intended to be aspirational in nature and are designed to provide suggestions to psychologists in working with ethnic, linguistic, and culturally diverse populations psychologists educate their clients to the processes of psychological intervention, such as goals and expectations. Politics the project looks into three categories of issues and claims arising in political life. For example, the indian constitution recognizes fifteen national languages. However, cultural pluralism did exist in a real sense. Between difference and inequality page 2 of 47 of linguistic inequality come from the pervasiveness of language, and from the increasingly and inescapably languaged nature of political, economic, and cultural life in the modern world. First recognized as an essential element of democracy by the philosophers of ancient greece, pluralism permits and even encourages a diversity of political opinion and participation. The issues of language and culture do impact on the provision of appropriate psychological services. Being a pluralistic state, indian has a great feeling of nationality and to generate or maintain this kind of feeling, the nature of our constitution is secular. Ethnicity and political pluralism in kenya electoral. The politics of cultural pluralism in ethiopia and eritrea.
In the american context, the development of pluralism as an idea is intertwined with questions of democracy, religion, race and ethnicity, and assimilation. Charles taylor the idea of a distinct entityan american was being widely pushed until it was firmly embedded in the american psyche by the beginning of the twentieth century. Now, when immigrants wanted to maintain their language or customs they were accused of being unamerican. Language is central to ethnic identity, and official language policies are often overlooked as critical factors in conflict over ethnic nationalism. Before exploring the differences within the pluralism family, it is necessary to draw the boundaries of pluralism visavis other competing philosophical views of social diversity. Liberal political scientists and philosophers, such as will kymlicka, charles taylor, chandran kukathas etc. This chapter continues to look at the ways in which ethnic and racial groups in the. Heterogeneity, regional autonomy, identity politics, ethnicity, religion, domination, conflict. Kearney, communaism and language in the politics of ceylon. Language policy has been at the heart of chinese nation building.
In order to read online pluralism at yale textbook, you need to create a free account. The multi ethnic nature of african societies was, of course, familiar to all, and indeed had long. Drawing on both sociolinguistics and political theory, the chapter. The colonial state represented a new type of polity, which emerged from the sixteenth century onwards. The major sources of religious inequality derive from religions thicker cultural, normative and political content, while the major sources of linguistic inequality come from the pervasiveness of language, and from the increasingly and inescapably languaged nature of political, economic and cultural life in. Maarif defines pluralism as keragaman budaya or cultural diversity p. Presentation of self in political life and norms of interaction. To argue that ethnic groups are unwitting tools of political. Far from heralding an age of diminishing loyalties to ethnic, linguistic, and regional identities, the increased ease with which finance, capital, and commodities move across borders stands in sharp contrast to tenacious affective and cultural ties and identities. An examination of language use online reveals that the issue is complex. The first is primarily social political, and targets the status regulation of the language.
Linguistic minorities, policies and pluralism sciencedirect. In this publication the reader will find articles reporting on empirical studies of pluralism in malaysian working life and education. Furthermore, the congress leaderships accommodation of people and of debates from across the ideological political spectrum enabled. Aside from inter ethnic violence, tensions based on individual and other group identities exist throughout the country. Download pluralism at yale book for free in pdf, epub. Colonial states, such as spain, in the americas, and britain and france in africa, differed fundamentally from patrimonial polities that had little interest in civilizing and transforming their subjects, even if they thought them barbarian. It focuses on the confusion surrounding cultural pluralism and assimilation. When we talk about pluralism from the political perspective, we mean. First, the model that puts nationality ahead parekh, 2008. Pdf language education, pluralism and citizenship researchgate. Pdf cultural pluralism on the example of national minorities in the.
The politics of cultural pluralism and ethnic conflict term. Ethnicity, especially when combined with territorial identity, is a reality that exists independently of political maneuvers. Pluralism is a political philosophy holding that people of different beliefs, backgrounds, and lifestyles can coexist in the same society and participate equally in the political process. The major sources of religious inequality derive from religions thicker cultural, normative and political content, while the major sources of linguistic inequality come from the pervasiveness of language, and from the increasingly and inescapably languaged nature of political, economic and cultural life in the modern world. Politics in plural societies scholars at harvard harvard university. The concept of cultural diversity, pluralism and plural societies the oxford talking dictionary of english defines pluralism as a form of society or state in which ethnic or cultural groups maintain their independent traditions, practices, and attitudes. In a political system based on democracy, fairness, and impartial justice, all groups will. In a pluralistic society, groups remain separate, and their cultural and. Cultural pluralism, when dominated by a concern for recognition, was symbolic it was symbolic in the sense that the large majority of the ethnic group derived a sense of satisfaction from the fact that they had been recognized, and that their own would surely look after their political interests and concerns. Religious pluralism in democratic societies ebook pdf. Feb 06, 2020 independent india was conceived as a celebration of indigenous diversity. Cultural pluralism and dilemmas of justice on jstor.
The politics of multiculturalism will be of special interest to students of southeast asian history and society, anthropologists grappling with questions of citizenship and culture, political scientists studying democracy across cultures, and all readers concerned with the prospects for civility and tolerance in a multicultural world. Accordingly, cultural, linguistic, gender and religious rights of indivi. Linguistic pluralism usually refers to the condition that exists when a community or country officially recognizes more than one language. We cannot guarantee that every book is in the library. The political status of the romani language in europe. The past decade has seen the emergence of linguistic pluralism in the use of romani in insti. Cultural and political pluralism, in turn, may or may not sprawl into a philosophical thesis. Turning away from policy discourses of preservation, protection, and heritage, we look at the grassroots strategies by which minority languages and cultural. Pdf pluralism and multiculturalism in colonial and postcolonial. Are the political discourses on pluralism relevant to the actual. In this article, we will break down pluralism and examine how it works in the real world. Abstract through what political, economic, cultural, and social processes is difference transformed into inequality.
Language is perhaps the most conspicuous of cultural assets which a minority may. Linguistic and cultural resilience in multi ethnic societies. Their different visions of pluralism became central to indian nationalism. Nonenglish colonials, often clustered in their own ethnic communities, did not necessarily feel any compulsion to forego their language and culture, nor did officials force them to do so. Ethnicity has a number of overlapping but different teferences,nanlely, racial origin, nationality, language and culture. Between difference and inequality page 1 of 47 linguistic and religious pluralism. Calls to restrict the political rights of ethnic minorities and favour the ethnic majority have been loud and steady since 2010. Cultural linguistic pluralism this is possible and desirable, although it may require a reinterpretation of our society in terms of a multi cultural community made up of individuals who speak natively a variety of different languages or dialects but share a common standardized tool of communication. This chapter describes ethnic diversity, language, and identity. The politics of cultural pluralism and ethnic conflict. Cultural linguistic pluralism and the problem of motivation. The second is more technical linguistic, and targets the body of linguistic material or corpus of the language.
In the 1950s, as democratization brought frequent competition, the issue of cultural pluralism came to the fore. Introductionglobalization is bringing new tensions and challenges to efforts to build pluralistic and inclusive societies. Prahalad centre for emerging india, loyola institute of business administration, chennai, calls attention to the need to reverse the current majoritarian and unitary tendencies. Traditionally, language planning is viewed as involving two activity domains. Cultural diversity an overview sciencedirect topics. Linguistic and cultural resilience in multi ethnic societies sustainable pluralism. Making the case for progressing from diversity to pluralism, m. In todays world, issues of cultural pluralism form an essential part of political. The founders set out to create a political system that could accommodate a. In chinese inner asia, any solution to ethnic conflict will include real linguistic and cultural autonomy for major ethnic groups. When we talk about pluralism from the political perspective, we mean the. Sinhala replaced english as the countrys official language, giving the. Heterogeneity, politics of ethnicity, and multiculturalism neliti.
New sets of values, beliefs, and cultural expectations have been introduced into educational, political, business, and healthcare systems by the physical presence of these groups. Three models of multicultural policy to deal with the reality of cultural plurality. Being a secular state india is a multicultural country. Theodore roosevelt, 26th president of the united states, 1907. While the internet has strengthened the need for an international lingua francaand that lingua franca is most frequently englishthere are present other online dynamics that contribute to new forms of language pluralism. Its defined as a condition in which many cultures coexist within a society and maintain their cultural differences. Indeed, the style prevailing in the past politics of cultural pluralism was symbolic. Rights and freedom of participating in cultural ethnic life 18911994 malawi got its independence from britain in 1964 and had its first multiparty democratic constitution voted into a full force on may 16, 1994. Kalam, anthropologist and professor of applied social sciences, c. Organized by the mershon research network in cultural resilience with the support of the mershon center for international security studies, the center for folklore studies, the department of linguistics, and the department of comparative studies of the ohio state university, and of osus 2014 andrew w. Far from heralding an age of diminishing loyalties to ethnic, linguistic, and regional identities, the increased ease with which finance, capital, and commodities. Ethnic and cultural pluralism in the colonial social order.
Ethnic conflict illustrates the difficulties that cultural pluralism poses. Nov 18, 2019 while the recognition of difference and the legitimacy of the other in themselves and in their form of community commits us to a kind of pluralism, the acknowledgement of cultural difference is the beginning rather than the end of the matter. The challenge of linguistic diversity and pluralism. This chapter is one of 16 that describe and examine each countrys linguistic and political history and the relation of its languages to national, ethnic, and cultural identities, while assessing. Whereas, article 30 1 is specific to religious and linguistic minorities. It states that all minorities, whether based on religion or language.
These do not exist as polar opposites, nor can the societies be characterized as either one or the other. The most lasting expression of ethnic jewishness in america was the political and cultural movement of zionism. Increased immigration flows, the collapse of communism, and the globalization of communications technologies have all fostered a wider variety of religious beliefs, practices, and organizations within and across democratic societies. Religious pluralism is everywhere in todays politics. Read as many books as you like personal use and join over 150. Apa guidelines for providers of services to ethnic. The challenge for identity all modern nations are more pluralistic in cultural, religious and political attitude than traditional communities which keep their integrity by means of a fundamentalistic ethnic culture and religion. These fault lines include linguistic divides between kyrgyz speakers and non. Steinberg is correct in saying that political pluralism did not exist. Sinhalese population a significant advantage in securing. Cultural pluralism seeks to overcome racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. Pluralism at yale download books pdfepub and read online. The linguistic and educational policies to which cultural pluralism gives rise are complicated. Cultural and linguistic diversity is the strength of india.
The management of cultural pluralism and diversity has become a focus of. The political philosophy of pluralism suggests that we really can and should all just get along. A key factor in both the maintenance of a yiddishkeit culture and the leftist politics of the immigrant community was the yiddish press, best represented by abraham cahans yiddish language progressive newspaper, the daily forward. Political philosophers tend to talk about race and gender much differently than they talk about religion.
19 1340 556 827 832 143 473 1482 457 614 699 708 916 1407 26 776 1402 19 573 512